Europa Universalis 5 update 1.4 released at the end of October, and made a lot of far-reaching changes to the fundamentals of Paradox Tinto’s historical grand strategy game. The many patches since launch had gradually brought the game’s performance to its knees, particularly as campaigns ran long. The developer acknowledges that “by 1.3 the late game was where quite a lot of you stopped playing due to slow performance.” The ‘Rio Salado’ update was all about fixing that, and it managed to make significant improvements – but along the way came the game’s most divisive change to date.
Prior to update 1.4, Europa Universalis 5 was using a tick system that simulated 12 steps for each and every day. “Nearly everything that matters in a war – how far an army moves, how long a battle lasts, how often an assault ticks – was measured in those steps,” Paradox Tinto explains. “You could never see them.” It says the change to a daily system was made not for performance reasons, although it did make EU5 run “about 10% faster,” but so that a single day was “the unit you think in,” making it easier to follow the pace that the simulation was moving as games progressed.
Responses to this change from a player survey “got more tens than any other question, and also more ones than any other question.” On the one side were players who “felt the game finally ran at the pace it should.” On the other, those who “felt we had thrown away simulation detail, and that battles had become slow and unresponsive.” There are arguments for both perspectives, depending on what matters to each player, although Paradox notes that the latter complaint “is a real problem and not a matter of taste.”

After much attempted fiddling and fixes, the team compromised, introducing a separate game rule with update 1.4.8 that allowed you to opt back into the finer-grain steps when in single player. “We said in Tinto Talks 130 that we underestimated the beta feedback on this, and I stand by that,” it admits. “When a change splits the players this cleanly, the right answer is a choice, not a verdict.”
Regarding the slower encounters, it remarks that feedback claimed “battles were too long and too short at the same time,” responding, “that is exactly right.” Battles were lasting for weeks, but resolving too quickly to watch or react to. While subsequent patches have improved factors like reserve spread and reinforcements stopping short if a battle ends before they arrive, and there’s also the hourly ticks toggle for those who want more granular combat, this slower movement is still not fixed on the daily tick. “We are not done here.”
The developer digs much more deeply into specific nuances of other systems in the 1.4 update for those who are curious, but its conclusion on the matter at large is where I want to focus. “Some of you may say, ‘Paradox never learns, they released buggy games before I was born,'” it writes. However, it lays down four mandates in response to this fiasco that it intends to stick to as Europa Universalis 5 looks to the future.

“First, communicate the goals when changing a core system.” By keeping its target for the likes of battle length in internal conversations rather than public documentation, players questioned whether there was a goal planned at all, rather than debating whether it was in the right place. “Second, smaller balance steps, more often.” Straightforward, but a good way to ensure a smoother flow.
Third is that beta tests are largely limited to the type of player that might dig deep into the weekly forum posts, but they don’t reach the broader audience who will be playing 1.4 at release, and nor did the test contain any of the new DLC. “We will be thinking about how to close that gap.” Finally, as previously suggested, “Where the players split, offer a choice. The time steps rule is the first time we have done that for something this central. It will not be the last time the question comes up.”
